
In 1897 Plekhanov reviewed the French translation of Antonio Labriola's essays on historical materialism, and used the review to set out what Marx's view of history is and what it is not. His Populist opponents called the Marxists "economic materialists", people who made the economy the one predominant "factor" in social life. Plekhanov answers that the whole theory of factors is the mistake: law, morals, politics and the economy are abstractions from a single history of social relations, shaped by the productive forces and passing into ideas through the social psychology of particular classes.
He also argues with Labriola, and on three points he wins: race explains nothing in the history of ideas, the earliest states arose from the needs of production as well as from class rule, and "ignorance" is something to be explained, not an explanation. Trotsky read the same essays in an Odessa prison cell in 1898, and never forgot them.
Written in 1897 under the pen name N. Kamensky. The Progress translation by Julius Katzer, from Selected Philosophical Works, Vol. II, Moscow, 1976, where it is titled "On the Materialist Understanding of History", with the edition's notes.
New critical introduction by Dmitry Chasovennikov.
| Series | The Progress Publishers Library |
| First published | 1897 |
| ISBN | 978-5-01-015170-6 |
| Pages | 50 |
| Language | English |
| Subject | Philosophy |
| Introduction By | Dmitry Chasovennikov |
| Translator | Julius Katzer |